top of page

Polyamorous vs open relationship: Do they work?


A poly relationship

In recent years, more and more people are changing how they approach relationships. Polyamorous and open relationships, once considered unconventional, are now gaining acceptance as valid alternatives to traditional monogamy.


As society evolves, individuals are exploring different ways to experience love and intimacy that align with their values. This blog explores the diverse world of polyamory, aiming to explain its complexities and share insights from people navigating multiple romantic connections.


It aims to answer questions like "Is this comfortable? Exciting? Or does it take time to adjust to such an approach to love, sex, and relationships?"



Polyamorous Relationship

Definition of polyamorous


A polyamorous relationship

Polyamory is the practice of openly sharing multiple loves. Unlike traditional forms of polygamy, polyamory is a rather recent cultural invention.


According to research conducted by the Institute for Advanced Study of Human Sexuality, people drawn to polyamory believe that natural human desires for more than one partner are best addressed by creating alternative, often utopian, forms of family. People are attracted to the poly world for diverse reasons.


Some, inspired by books such as Robert Heinlein’s Stranger in a Strange Land, hope to actualize a gender and relationship utopia in their own lives. Others, frustrated by years of restrictive monogamous marriage/relationship agreements, endeavor to better address their attraction to multiple partners.


Still others are independent idealists who believe that expressions of love should not be restricted by religion and the law.


How do polyamorous relationships work


Polyamorous partners having a good time

The most common poly relationship is the open couple. Sometimes these are described as “polyamorous with a primary partner,” “polyamorous with multiple primary partners,” or “polyamorous with primary and secondary partners.”


While difficult to actualize, some poly people very much seek to be part of a triad

(threesome) or quad (foursome).


Some poly couples aim to give their consent or approve their lover’s liaisons before they occur. Here, formal introductions might be required. Typically, the scrutinizing partner would want to ensure that this potential new love has no intention of undermining the existing relationship. Issues of safety might be considered.


Would this new love agree to rules regarding safe sex, privacy, and honesty? Are they emotionally secure enough to not make overwhelming demands for time and attention? And finally, would their presence add good things to their poly family?


Some poly couples adhere to strict “date nights,” endeavoring to restrict visits with outside lovers to designated times. Others allow such visiting only when out of town at conferences, on business, etc.


Are Polyamorous relationships healthy?


It is subjective, and individuals may have varying perspectives on the health of polyamorous relationships but from my point of view, if you are not suited for such a relationship it can be an unhealthy experience here are some reasons why


  • Balancing time and attention among multiple partners can be demanding, potentially leading to feelings of neglect or a sense that one's needs are not being adequately met. Juggling the emotional needs and expectations of multiple partners can be mentally and emotionally exhausting. It may lead to stress, anxiety, and feelings of guilt or inadequacy.

  • Managing emotions like jealousy and insecurity can be more complex in polyamorous setups, and not everyone feels equipped to navigate these challenges successfully. Since individuals are allowed to have multiple partners this can amplify feelings of jealousy and insecurity, as individuals may worry about how they measure up to others or fear being replaced.

  • Effective communication is crucial in polyamorous relationships, and some individuals may find the level of communication required to be overwhelming or exhausting.

  • External judgments and societal stigma can impact individuals in polyamorous relationships, potentially causing stress or discomfort.

  • For some, the ethical and moral implications of being involved in multiple romantic relationships may conflict with personal values, leading to a sense of discomfort or guilt.


Generally speaking, the intricacies of managing multiple relationships simultaneously can be challenging, and some individuals may find the complexity of polyamory to be emotionally draining which will not be good for their health.




Does a Polyamory relationship work?


An illustration of how polyamory works

The success of polyamorous relationships is subjective and varies from person to person. Like any form of relationship, they demand effort, understanding, and effective communication. Polyamorous relationships are inherently complex, presenting lots of challenges.


While initially the thought (and experience) of sharing one’s lover with another person may be thoroughly revolting, eventually one has yelled and screamed and cried so much that the initial charge fades.


The Doctor of Philosophy stated in her research that, "The Luo co-wives I spoke to in Eastern Kenya told me it takes about two years to adjust to sharing one’s husband with another wife. Sometimes the thought or actuality of violence may trigger a transformation. A husband in Northern California loaded bullets into his rifle after he walked into his wife’s bedroom and saw her in bed ix with her poly lover. Rather than pulling the trigger, he confessed his thoughts to his wife the next morning and they worked hard to reconcile unresolved feelings."


However, for many individuals, polyamory is a fulfilling and authentic way of expressing their love and connection with others. Not everyone is suited to polyamory, and it's crucial for those considering this relationship style to have a deep understanding of their own needs.


Many individuals who embrace polyamory do so because it aligns with their core identity and emotional needs. For them, polyamorous relationships offer a unique and satisfying way to form connections, and share love but may not be the right way to attempt a relationship.




Open relationships

Open relationship meaning


A couple in an open relationship

Open relationships refer to a type of intimate relationship where individuals mutually agree to have consensual romantic or sexual connections with people outside of the primary partnership.


The emphasis is often on the freedom to explore physical or sexual connections with others while maintaining the primary emotional connection with one's partner.


It is not like a polyamorous relationship where the people involved have multiple romantic and/or emotional relationships with the knowledge and consent of everyone involved.


How does an open relationship work?


Alex and Taylor have been in a committed relationship for several years and have recently decided to explore an open relationship. They've had open and honest communication about their desires, and both feel secure in their commitment to each other.


They discuss their comfort levels and potential concerns. They set clear boundaries to guide their interactions with others. For instance, they decide that sexual encounters with others are acceptable but that emotional connections outside the primary partnership should be communicated and discussed openly.


Alex meets someone at a social event and feels a mutual attraction. Before taking things further, Alex communicates with Taylor about the situation. They discuss the boundaries in place and ensure that both are comfortable with the potential connection.


If Taylor expresses any concerns, they work together to understand and address them, adjusting their agreement if necessary.


When your partner wants an open relationship


How open relationships work

When your partner expresses a desire for an open relationship, it's essential to approach the situation openly and honestly. Take some time to think about your feelings and values, considering whether an open relationship aligns with what you want.


Have a sincere and non-judgmental conversation with your partner to understand their reasons and share your thoughts and concerns. If you feel the need for guidance, consider talking to a couple of trusted friends for advice and perspective.


Friends can provide valuable insights, helping you make a decision that will align with your motives and what you want. If what you want is not an open relationship then let your partner know.


Do open relationships work?


In an open relationship, partners agree to have sexual relationships with other people. However, the success of this arrangement can be complicated, particularly because not everyone can easily separate emotions from sex.


Unlike many men, not all women find it straightforward to detach emotions from intimate encounters. Engaging in an open relationship can be risky, as emotional attachments may develop with other partners.


Even if there are rules, such as not having repeated encounters or engaging only with strangers, there remains a high likelihood of developing stronger-than-intended attractions. This raises the concern that a spouse may become emotionally drawn to someone else, either due to powerful sexual attraction or the evolution of emotional connections over time.


Consider this: if sharing your favorite dress or a cherished object feels uncomfortable, then sharing your partner's body might seem even more challenging. It raises questions about the depth of romantic love in the relationship.


It suggests that perhaps the motivation for agreeing to an open relationship is more about some desires rather than a genuine search for a real connection with someone. In either scenario, it raises concerns about the overall happiness and fulfillment in the relationship.



Final Remarks


In conclusion, open relationships and polyamory can offer fulfilling experiences for individuals seeking diverse connections. If the primary goal is to explore and have fun while maintaining transparent communication and mutual consent, these relationship styles can be well-suited. However, it's not suited for everyone, and if you don't think you can handle such a relationship it will be better to stay away from such.



Comments


bottom of page